Minimum wage laws have a long history and enduring. As you may recall, milton friedman debated former health, education, and welfare secretary wilbur cohen on meanstesting social security back in 1972. Public opinion notwithstanding, social security, not welfare, is the policy disaster. In contrast, restaurant employment outside the city grew at a 1. Free market architect of social reaction by nick beams 21 november 2006 in his afterword to the second edition of capital in 1873, karl marx noted that the.
Minimumwage rates by milton friedman newsweek, 26 september 1966 the newsweekdaily beast company llc congress has just acted to increase unemployment. If the employees tips combined with the hourly wage do not equal the minimum wage, the employer must make up the difference. The minimum wage is not only ineffective, it is plainly immoral. Within a year the minimum wage will fall to a fortyyear low in purchasing power. There is nothing simpler than stopping an inflationfrom the technical point of view. In february 1973, he gave an interview to playboy magazine and is. Yet, milton friedmans confident assertion that a higher minimum wage will undoubtedly lead to greater unemployment is perhaps the purest example of the classical school of thought on minimum wage legislation and its impact on employment rates. However, smiths relevance to a minimum wage boost is a bit of a leap discussing economic mobility, the president quoted adam smith to prove that even the father of freemarket economics would have supported an increase in the minimum wage. Milton friedmans methodology of positive economics was a plea for a positivistic interplay of theory and observation. The negative effects of minimum wage laws cato institute. Milton friedman explained in capitalism and freedom. Become engaged in a community that shares an interest in the mission of the hoover institution to advance policy ideas that promote economic opportunity and prosperity, while securing and safeguarding peace for america and all mankind.
The great one begins with his characteristically brilliant contrarianism. What milton friedman got right and wrong about welfare. Milton friedman proposed to give everybody free money in his book capitalism and freedom. Far from benefitting them, it is a positive hann to those at the bottom of the labor market. Milton friedman and walter williams on minimumwage. Whether friedman was right or notthat is, whether capitalism does in fact result in less inequality, as he claimedis a question that presumably can be settled by research. Fifty years later, this explanation of the case for a basic income laid out by milton friedman is more relevant than ever. The intriguing question, however, is why a libertarian such as milton friedman should be concerned with inequality at all.
This file is licensed under the creative commons attributionshare alike 3. Friedman was describing his plan for a negative income tax, a plan actually introduced and promoted by nixon, but the skeleton of that case applies to just about any system of universal needsbased support. Perhaps one of the more interesting data points from last weeks employment report is displayed in the graph above, which shows that the jobless rate for black male teens aged 1619 years increased to 40. Because it would be wonderful if we all knew adam smith, i was delighted that president obama quoted him in a recent speech. Today is equal pay day, which is the day on which the median earnings of female workers starting from the first day of the previous year january 1, 20 in this case to today equals the median earnings of male workers for only the previous year. Now if one takes more than econ 101 one would know that markets are more complicated than simple supply and demand models. Milton friedman was an american economist and statistician best known for his strong belief in freemarket capitalism. Milton friedman on the minimum wage american experiment.
Friedrich hayek supported a guaranteed minimum income by james kwak we shall again take for granted the availability of a system of public relief which provides a uniform minimum for all instances of proved need, so that no member of the community need be in want of food or shelter. July 24, 2016 marks seven years since the federal minimum wage was last increased. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in. Milton friedman described minimum wage legislation as a law.
Friedrich hayek supported a guaranteed minimum income. The indiana minimum wage law also prohibits pay discrimination on the basis of sex. Why milton friedman supported a guaranteed income 5 reasons. Bernanke at the conference to honor milton friedman, university of chicago, chicago, illinois november 8, 2002 on milton friedmans ninetieth birthday12. To evaluate the impact of the law we surveyed 410 fastfood restaurants in new jersey and eastern pennsylvania before and after the rise. Hilton san francisco union square june 28july 2, 2019 annual 94 conference th western economic association international 2018sanfranciscocover94thfinal.
Raising minimum wage not the solution voice for liberty. Minimum wage kills jobs and hurts those which it intends. If someone doesnt have enough skills to produce enough for a company to justify the current minimum wage level, they wont be employed, unless that particular business is in the business of losing money. More and more americans are working hard without a raise.
Milton friedman has 110 books on goodreads with 74722 ratings. He mostly referred to this plan as a negative income. In a 1955 essay, milton friedman proposed exactly that. Its undeniable, but dont take my word for it, heres the late milton friedman, who won the nobel price in economics in the 1970s. Ht mark perry i wonder if the laborunion lobbyists mentioned at the start of the clip by friedman as having prominently testified before congress for a hike in the minimum wage were. There are several conclusions one can draw from an analysis of the minimum wage, and all are negative.
As friedman emphasized, inflation is an old, old disease. During his time as professor at the university of chicago, friedman. He was awarded the nobel prize for economics in 1976 education and career. No, it tried to be a rational argument and it tried to consider the evidence for the points that are made. Friedman was one year old when his family moved from brooklyn, new york, to rahway. Books by milton friedman author of capitalism and freedom. Minimum wage laws are about as clear a case as one can find of a measure the effects of which are precisely the opposite of those intended by the men of good will who support it. The consensus is uncertain if it makes it harder to find work, agree that its a beneficial policy.
The minimum wage in ontario, alberta, and british columbia. Nobel prizewinning economist milton friedman said, one of the great mistakes is to judge policies and. They also should make paying taxes so simple think flat tax simple with. Milton friedman once called minimum wage one of the most, if not the most, antiblack laws we have on the statute books for its perceived consequence of decreasing employment among the less skilled workers in the labor force.
Thus, a large increase in minimum wage hurts unskilled workers. Milton friedman was an economist with a rare gift for translating technical arguments into clear prose as you will find at length in his books capitalism and freedom and free to choose. This report documents the rhetorical onslaught launched by minimum wage opponents over the past 100 years. I agree with milton friedman, many employers are focused on maximizing profit and will hire less workers if minimum wage gets too high. The economics of minimum wage legislation revisited.
Pdf the debate on the economic effects of minimum wage. A system of educational vouchers, where governments require a minimal level of schooling and provide parents with vouchers redeem able for that schooling at any certified institution of the parents choice. If you really want to get a feeling about the minimum wage, theres nothing more instructive than going to the congressional documents to read the. Information about the federal minimum wage is available. Employers will want to hire the most skilled workers first and the least skilled workers last. Milton friedman, born july 31, 1912, brooklyn, new york, u. This 12minuteplus clip from milton friedmans 1980 free to choose series is on the minimum wage. Milton friedman discusses the effects of minimum wage, dispelling the myth that it is a good thing. Following minimum wage increases, unemployment spikes. In 1962, the libertarian economist milton friedman advocated a minimum guaranteed income via a negative income tax. An interview with milton friedman chapman university. They also should seek to simplify minimum wage structures, and consider eliminating it all together for those industries where pay for performance measures are a fairer approach. Against the minimum wage frontier centre for public policy.
Pdf the minimum wage establishment has its origin in the first third of the last century. Do you agree with milton friedmans stance on minimum wage. The minimum wage actually creates unemployment for the unskilled. Price controls, of lessons for the young economist, by robert p. It is immoral to say that people with low skills are not allowed to work. Milton friedmans most popular book is capitalism and freedom. The conservative case for a guaranteed basic income. Minimumwage rates collected works of milton friedman. Those who want to purchase education beyond the minimum would of course be free. But the minimum wage has never reached the floor set for a living income and has not, therefore, appreciably reduced the bill for wage subsidies.
701 852 1188 879 1340 561 1303 170 1565 1 1374 1581 20 1494 56 1538 213 1528 1390 27 1123 1032 1598 1319 1568 1133 597 40 623 948 1279 783 1112 984 1170 788 1361 261